Total Pageviews

Tuesday, 3 June 2025

Scottish Independence; Why is this my fight? (529)

 Che Guevara was not Cuban. This is my shorthand answer when English friends ask in a bemused fashion, a woman of Caribbean descent, born in the shire counties of England, without a drop of Scottish blood, is so passionate about Scottish Independence.

I could also add that, in fact, there may be Scottish ancestry somewhere. With a name like Crawford lurking on the peripheries of my family – the most likely explanation is a Scottish slave owner somewhere in the past. We’ll leave that one.

I could go on to say that, even more so as a mixed-race person born into a comfortable working-class household in the early 1960s, I was aware in an abstract way that I was not only different from almost everyone around me at school and everyone in my immediate neighbourhood but also not entirely ‘in’ with the black immigrants of my maternal family when we were in Birmingham. A sense of ‘other’ leads, I suspect, to lack of ties to contemporary groups. The up-side is that I never felt the pull of peer pressure as quite simply I felt I was never part of the group. Hence no peers to be pressured by.

And on I could go, waffling into the long grass.

The truth I suspect is closer to the first short explanation on which I will expand.

Sometimes you have fight in you. Sometimes you have an innate sense of injustice. Where it comes from, I cannot say other than I’ve always had it. I do not come from a political family but on leaving home to study in Newcastle I was pretty soon engulfed in a political battle that could not have been further from my roots if it had involved invaders from Mars; The 1984/5 Miners’ Strike. A battle ostensibly of white working-class men in an industry I had no experience of and little knowledge of. But I campaigned, I marched, I took the student buses to London and experienced first-hand the grim, untethered aggression of angry ‘encounters’ involving a police force that knew it had carte-blanche to horse charge and use batons whether against miners or students.

Thatcher’s collective punishment beating of the working class marked a dark and dangerous turning point which began to unravel the post-war gains for ordinary people. These significant gains were born of the horrors of the Second World War and an acknowledgment that you could not send ordinary people, en masse, to die on the battle fields, leave widows to bring up children and continue to treat vast swathes of the populous as 3rd class.

But it felt like my battle. Why? I could not have explained at the time but it led in the end to me joining the Labour Party – which is ironic as then leader Neil Kinnock arguably did little to support the miners. Perhaps secretly hoping that Thatcher would clip the union’s wings and curb some of the power of the very movement that was the genesis of the party he led.

In reality there followed an avalanche of societal destruction which may not have been obvious as such at the time (it was obvious to some ref: Making it Public by Dexter Whitfield. Pluto Press 1983) but which – looking back – was a wholesale restructuring of social orders, bringing us to a present day where everything that was in private hands before that war – and much that was not – is back in the hands of the wealthy – with this one caveat. The state now subsidises these private entities and much of that money ends up off-shore in private hands – very often foreign hands despite the Right Wingers being the loudest to bleat about patriotism.

Later – though still young as a city councillor (at 23) I was one of a couple of lone voices to argue against what we called The Poll Tax and was carpeted by then Council leader Jeremy Beecham and his creepy side kick Tony Flynn. I made a nuisance of myself complaining about the abuse of councillor’s expenses. This was back in the day when – despite the fact that councils actually ran services directly rather than simply deciding which of their mates to award contracts to – there was no stipend so those who thought they were entitled used to ‘play the expenses system’ and Jeremy Beecham was able to behave like a feudal lord handing out favours to the obedient in the form of chair positions of prominent committees.

I won’t go on about that sad episode – suffice to say – I couldn’t stomach it and after being elected a second term, I resigned before its conclusion when I realised ‘dealing with’ bullying and abuse was pointless – achieving nothing. I let my membership run until the illegal invasion of Iraq then resigned that too and swore off party politics.

THEN I moved to Scotland.

What I discover was people with a strange accent speaking my language. I found folk who – on the whole did not look like me but with whom I felt a connection.

I discovered a political ideology that was what I’d firstly assumed and then hoped The Labour Party was about.

I discovered a social structure – albeit imperfect and horribly restricted by devilish devolution – that actually still cared about human beings in a humane way.

It was a revelation.

And – what is even more astonishing is that – while I did – many years later – get over my disgust at party politics and join the SNP – I have found that the touchstone of my drive, my desire for justice, my need for fairness, accountability and the dignity of people is served better in the grass roots Independence movement – The Yes groups that are dotted over Scotland, sparked by the 2014 referendum.

Why is this so odd? Well – in many ways the Yes groups seem to me to be more ‘culturally’ Scottish than the SNP. So – as someone who’s not a fan of haggis or bagpipes (though, who doesn’t like a guy in a kilt?) I at first did not understand this affinity.

In fact, I’ve been on street stalls where other English born people have wandered over for a chat and when we’ve laid out what we do they respond – ‘oh, I’m English, it’s nothing to do with me’. To which the collective response – in our group is – and in every group should be – if you live in Scotland, it’s your business.

Why?

Sometimes you have the fight in you. You have the burning need for justice. And what I re-discovered having discovered it once in the Miners’ Strike as a student – it doesn’t have to be your fight. It only needs to be a parallel.

I cannot fight the injustice of my ancestors. There is no land to reclaim, there is no route back to those roots. But the fight is in me and I see a similar fight here and I want in. I want in really badly.

I want to see freedom, dignity and independence and the right to self-governance for those who live in Scotland now as if it is my freedom and my wrong.

It helps for purposes of clarity that Westminster – whether under Labour or Conservative - has continued blindly and cruelly in the colonial mindset and shows no empathy for the ordinary people of this land. It helps that they have shown a callousness that is unequivocal whether it be to the tens of thousands of Middle Eastern civilians they condemned to body bags and unmarked graves in Iraq and subsequently Gaza. It helps rub out any distinction on this side now they have abandoned poor children, the homeless, the elderly, women and young people. Is there anyone the incumbents of Westminster have not abandoned in the pursuit of power?

It is sad that large swathes of the populous have swallowed the lies that economic woes and decline are the fault of the poor, the destitute and the migrant. Have they squandered the wealth of land and industry? No. Nothing could be further from the truth.

In a post-Brexit society where bigotry has been legitimised and the last and current Westminster administrations have failed to move public focus away from migrant-blaming in order to protect the failures of the historic ruling classes and their increasing, stand subsidised fortunes, it behoves the more enlightened Scottish government and the grass-roots independence movement to shift the dial.

We must openly acknowledge the historic contributions of generations of migrants have made to Scotland.

We must loudly celebrate the energy, hard work, and vitality of those who have chosen to make this their home.

In the interests of a strong, united, successful future independent Scotland we must be unequivocal about its welcome to those who come here to raise families, contribute to the nation of Scotland.

We must not only continue to reject the harmful, corrosive, poisonous scapegoating of the vulnerable – whether on a domestic level or those fleeing countries devastated by Westminster’s continuing colonial mindset but to make sure that – as the situation is now, clearly vacant – Scotland welcomes ‘the tired, the poor, the huddled masses yearning to breathe free’. Because migrants have always nourished the worn soil of tired nations from the Irish road builders and potato pickers to Romanian nurses, Polish plumbers and African care workers and it is – as we all know – the avaricious few at the top of the pile who suck society dry.

That truth has been turned on its head and we need to openly and publicly and loudly set the record straight.

Not only is that the right thing to do it opens the door to welcoming in a whole army of friends and new allies to the Independence movement who are still ambiguous as to whether it has anything to do with them.

The battle is upon us.

Yes, lethargy and the disconnect of a populous that is weary and disengaged is against us.

A complicit predominantly right-wing media is against us.

The monied interests that rely on tax subsidies to shore up their profits are against us.

The narrative that our failing infrastructure and crumbling services are the fault of desperate people in boats and the feckless on benefits is as unwavering as it is untrue.

The cowardice of those who gain power and then do not wish to rock the boat they float in is against us.

But we must fight anyhow.

And, whatever their colour or creed, I’ll stand next to anyone who will stand next to me.

*

Thanks for reading.

As always do check out my audio stuff on Bandcamp and My BOOKS 

Also - if you have kids - I've opened up the poetry for children (rather rough) vids that I put on youtube for my grandkids - so enjoy these too Fruit Salad Person

The last one is a bit bonkers but remember I put them up for my grandkids...